Elektrine lite

← Feed

@soop@wetdry.world

2025-09-07 11:43 UTC

myth: bs is decentralized fact: it's a centralized platform with an interoperability gimmick whether you like it or not the entire atproto network is defined and controlled by bluesky pbllc, and there's no good faith to be had in that bigoted corpo. they will not promote decentalization, there's nothing in it for them, stop making overly optimistic assumptions about a platform that would be defederated by most of fedi be it a mastodon instance

Replies (2)

  • @hexaheximal@mstdn.social 2025-09-07 12:02

    @soop@wetdry.world the protocol design itself is decentralized, but as I said earlier that isn't enough to make full selfhosting (the actual pds is easy though) practical since: 1. relays require massive amounts of bandwidth since they receive everything on he network in realtime 2. appviews require a large amount of storage (iirc it was like 20tb?) because it's indxexing the entire network 3. most users just use a bluesky pds, so they have won the network effect: see https://arewedecentralizedyet.online/

    Open ##3212338

  • @Li@tech.lgbt 2025-09-07 12:59

    @soop@wetdry.world i would say bsky is decentralized in theroy* in the same way email is* that is, in theory it could be decentralized, and it's made with a level of decentralization in its design and protocols and whatnot. but in practice, its run by a major tech conglomerate, who pretty much controls 100% of everything that happens then; keep in mind the bar for 'decentralization' in the first sense is actually quite low, requiring only that the ability to run it yourself is technically doable; to a kinda liberal sense where even Nintendo Network is "decentralized" because pretendo is open source so you ""could"" run your own server, (even if no one does,)

    Open ##3212343