2025-09-07 11:43 UTC
Replies (2)
-
@hexaheximal@mstdn.social 2025-09-07 12:02
@soop@wetdry.world the protocol design itself is decentralized, but as I said earlier that isn't enough to make full selfhosting (the actual pds is easy though) practical since: 1. relays require massive amounts of bandwidth since they receive everything on he network in realtime 2. appviews require a large amount of storage (iirc it was like 20tb?) because it's indxexing the entire network 3. most users just use a bluesky pds, so they have won the network effect: see https://arewedecentralizedyet.online/
-
@Li@tech.lgbt 2025-09-07 12:59
@soop@wetdry.world i would say bsky is decentralized in theroy* in the same way email is* that is, in theory it could be decentralized, and it's made with a level of decentralization in its design and protocols and whatnot. but in practice, its run by a major tech conglomerate, who pretty much controls 100% of everything that happens then; keep in mind the bar for 'decentralization' in the first sense is actually quite low, requiring only that the ability to run it yourself is technically doable; to a kinda liberal sense where even Nintendo Network is "decentralized" because pretendo is open source so you ""could"" run your own server, (even if no one does,)